|
Geothermal Heat Pumps
www.GeothermalHeatPumps.net
We
provide Cooler, Cleaner, Greener Power
& Energy Solutions™ project
development services that are Kyoto Protocol compliant and generate
clean energy and significantly reduce carbon dioxide emissions. Unlike
most companies, we are equipment supplier/vendor neutral. This means we
help our clients select the best equipment for their specific
application. This approach provides our customers with superior
performance, decreased operating expenses and increased return on
investment.
Cogeneration
Technologies, located in Houston, Texas, provides
project development services that generate clean energy and
significantly reduce greenhouse
gas emissions and carbon
dioxide emissions. Included in this are our
turnkey "ecogeneration™"
products and services which includes renewable
energy technologies, waste to
energy, waste to watts™ and waste
heat recovery solutions. Other project development
technologies include; Anaerobic
Digester, Anaerobic Lagoon, Biogas
Recovery, BioMethane, Biomass
Gasification, and Landfill Gas
To Energy, project development services.
Unlike
most companies, we are equipment supplier/vendor neutral. This means we
help our clients select the best equipment for their specific
application. This approach provides our customers with superior
performance, decreased operating expenses and increased return on
investment.
Products and
services provided by Cogeneration Technologies includes the following
power and energy project development services:
-
Project
Engineering Feasibility & Economic Analysis Studies
-
Engineering,
Procurement and Construction
-
Environmental
Engineering & Permitting
-
Project
Funding & Financing Options; including Equity Investment, Debt
Financing, Lease and Municipal Lease
-
Shared/Guaranteed
Savings Program with No Capital Investment from Qualified Clients
-
Project
Commissioning
-
3rd
Party Ownership and Project Development
-
Long-term
Service Agreements
-
Operations
& Maintenance
-
Green
Tag (Renewable Energy Credit, Carbon Dioxide Credits, Emission
Reduction Credits) Brokerage Services; Application and Permitting
We
are Renewable Energy
Technologies specialists and develop clean power and energy projects
that will generate a "Renewable
Energy Credit," Carbon
Dioxide Credits and Emission
Reduction Credits. Some of our products and services solutions
and technologies include; Absorption
Chillers, Adsorption Chillers,
Automated Demand Response, Biodiesel
Refineries, Biofuel Refineries,
Biomass Gasification, BioMethane,
Canola Biodiesel, Coconut
Biodiesel, Cogeneration, Concentrating
Solar Power, Demand Response
Programs, Demand Side
Management, Energy
Conservation Measures, Energy
Master Planning, Engine Driven
Chillers, Geothermal Heatpumps,
Groundsource Heatpumps, Solar
CHP, Solar Cogeneration, Rapeseed
Biodiesel, Solar Electric
Heat Pumps, Solar
Electric Power Systems, Solar
Heating and Cooling, Solar
Trigeneration, Soy Biodiesel, Trigeneration,
and Watersource Heatpumps.
Unlike
most companies, we are equipment supplier/vendor neutral. This means we
help our clients select the best equipment for their specific
application. This approach provides our customers with superior
performance, decreased operating expenses and increased return on
investment.
For more information: call us at: 832-758-0027
Geothermal
Heat Pumps

Two 36-ton geothermal heat pumps.
The geothermal
heat pump, also known as the ground source heat pump, water-source heat
pump, and earth-coupled heat pump, is a highly efficient renewable
energy technology that is gaining wide acceptance for both residential
and commercial buildings. Geothermal heat pumps are used for space
heating and cooling, as well as water heating. Its great advantage is
that it works by concentrating naturally existing heat, rather than by
producing heat through combustion of fossil fuels.
The
technology relies on the fact that the Earth (beneath the surface)
remains at a relatively constant temperature throughout the year, warmer
than the air above it during the winter and cooler in the summer, very
much like a cave. The geothermal heat pump takes advantage of this by
transferring heat stored in the Earth or in ground water into a building
during the winter, and transferring it out of the building and back into
the ground during the summer. The ground, in other words, acts as a heat
source in winter and a heat sink in summer.
The
system includes three principal components:
-
Geothermal
earth connection subsystem
-
Geothermal
heat pump subsystem
-
Geothermal
heat distribution subsystem.
Earth
Connection
Using
the Earth as a heat source/sink, a series of pipes, commonly called a
"loop," is buried in the ground near the building to be
conditioned. The loop can be buried either vertically or horizontally.
It circulates a fluid (water, or a mixture of water and antifreeze) that
absorbs heat from, or relinquishes heat to, the surrounding soil,
depending on whether the ambient air is colder or warmer than the soil.
Heat
Pump
For
heating, a geothermal heat pump removes the heat from the fluid in the
Earth connection, concentrates it, and then transfers it to the
building. For cooling, the process is reversed.
Heat
Distribution
Conventional
ductwork is generally used to distribute heated or cooled air from the
geothermal heat pump throughout the building.
Residential
Hot Water
In
addition to space conditioning, geothermal heat pumps can be used to
provide domestic hot water when the system is operating. Many
residential systems are now equipped with desuperheaters that transfer
excess heat from the geothermal heat pump's compressor to the house's
hot water tank. A desuperheater provides no hot water during the spring
and fall when the geothermal heat pump system is not operating; however,
because the geothermal heat pump is so much more efficient than other
means of water heating, manufacturers are beginning to offer "full
demand" systems that use a separate heat exchanger to meet all of a
household's hot water needs. These units cost-effectively provide hot
water as quickly as any competing system.
Types
of Geothermal Heat Pump Systems
There
are four basic types of ground loop systems. Three of
these—horizontal, vertical, and pond/lake—are closed-loop systems.
The fourth type of system is the open-loop option. Which one of these is
best depends on the climate, soil conditions, available land, and local
installation costs at the site. All of these approaches can be used for
residential and commercial building applications.
Closed-Loop
Systems
Horizontal
This
type of installation is generally most cost-effective for residential
installations, particularly for new construction where sufficient land
is available. It requires trenches at least four feet deep. The most
common layouts either use two pipes, one buried at six feet, and the
other at four feet, or two pipes placed side-by-side at five feet in the
ground in a two-foot wide trench. The Slinky™ method of looping pipe
allows more pipe in a shorter trench, which cuts down on installation
costs and makes horizontal installation possible in areas it would not
be with conventional horizontal applications.
Vertical
Large
commercial buildings and schools often use vertical systems because the
land area required for horizontal loops would be prohibitive. Vertical
loops are also used where the soil is too shallow for trenching, and
they minimize the disturbance to existing landscaping. For a vertical
system, holes (approximately four inches in diameter) are drilled about
20 feet apart and 100–400 feet deep. Into these holes go two pipes
that are connected at the bottom with a U-bend to form a loop. The
vertical loops are connected with horizontal pipe (i.e., manifold),
placed in trenches, and connected to the heat pump in the building.
Pond/Lake
If
the site has an adequate water body, this may be the lowest cost option.
A supply line pipe is run underground from the building to the water and
coiled into circles at least eight feet under the surface to prevent
freezing. The coils should only be placed in a water source that meets
minimum volume, depth, and quality criteria.
Open-Loop
System
This
type of system uses well or surface body water as the heat exchange
fluid that circulates directly through the GHP system. Once it has
circulated through the system, the water returns to the ground through
the well, a recharge well, or surface discharge. This option is
obviously practical only where there is an adequate supply of relatively
clean water, and all local codes and regulations regarding groundwater
discharge are met.
Benefits
of Geothermal Heat Pump Systems
The
biggest benefit of GHPs is that they use 25%–50% less electricity than
conventional heating or cooling systems. This translates into a GHP
using one unit of electricity to move three units of heat from the
earth. According to the EPA, geothermal heat pumps can reduce energy
consumption—and corresponding emissions—up to 44% compared to
air-source heat pumps and up to 72% compared to electric resistance
heating with standard air-conditioning equipment. GHPs also improve
humidity control by maintaining about 50% relative indoor humidity,
making GHPs very effective in humid areas.
Geothermal
heat pump systems allow for design flexibility and can be installed in
both new and retrofit situations. Because the hardware requires less
space than that needed by conventional HVAC systems, the equipment rooms
can be greatly scaled down in size, freeing space for productive use.
GHP systems also provide excellent "zone" space conditioning,
allowing different parts of your home to be heated or cooled to
different temperatures.
Because
GHP systems have relatively few moving parts, and because those parts
are sheltered inside a building, they are durable and highly reliable.
The underground piping often carries warranties of 25–50 years, and
the heat pumps often last 20 years or more. Since they usually have no
outdoor compressors, GHPs are not susceptible to vandalism. On the other
hand, the components in the living space are easily accessible, which
increases the convenience factor and helps ensure that the upkeep is
done on a timely basis.
Because
they have no outside condensing units like air conditioners, there's no
concern about noise outside the home. A two-speed GHP system is so quiet
inside a house that users do not know it is operating: there are no
tell-tale blasts of cold or hot air.
Selecting
and Installing a Geothermal Heat Pump System
Heating
and Cooling Efficiency of Geothermal Heat Pumps
The
heating efficiency of ground-source and water-source heat pumps is
indicated by their coefficient of performance (
COP
), which is the ratio of heat provided in Btu per Btu of energy input.
Their cooling efficiency is indicated by the Energy Efficiency Ratio (EER),
which is the ratio of the heat removed (in Btu per hour) to the
electricity required (in watts) to run the unit. Look for the ENERGY
STAR
label, which indicates a heating
COP
of 2.8 or greater and an EER of 13 or greater.
Manufacturers
of high-efficiency geothermal heat pumps voluntarily use the EPA ENERGY
STAR
label on qualifying equipment and related product literature. If you are
purchasing a geothermal heat pump and uncertain whether it meets ENERGY
STAR
qualifications, ask for an efficiency rating of at least 2.8
COP
or 13 EER.
Many
geothermal heat pump systems carry the U.S. Department of Energy (DOE)
and EPA ENERGY
STAR
label. ENERGY
STAR
-labeled equipment can now be financed with special ENERGY
STAR
loans from banks and other financial institutions. The goal of the loan
program is to make ENERGY
STAR
equipment easier to purchase, so ENERGY
STAR
loans were created with attractive terms. Some loans have lower interest
rates, longer repayment periods, or both. Ask your contractor about
ENERGY
STAR
loans or call the ENERGY
STAR
toll-free hotline at 1-888-
STAR
-YES for a list of financing options.
Economics
of Geothermal Heat Pumps
Geothermal
heat pumps save money in operating and maintenance costs. While the
initial purchase price of a residential GHP system is often higher than
that of a comparable gas-fired furnace and central air-conditioning
system, it is more efficient, thereby saving money every month. For
further savings, GHPs equipped with a device called a "desuperheater"
can heat the household water. In the summer cooling period, the heat
that is taken from the house is used to heat the water for free. In the
winter, water heating costs are reduced by about half.
On
average, a geothermal heat pump system costs about $2,500 per ton of
capacity, or roughly $7,500 for a 3-ton unit (a typical residential
size). ). A system using horizontal ground loops will generally cost
less than a system with vertical loops. In comparison, other systems
would cost about $4,000 with air conditioning.
Although
initially more expensive to install than conventional systems, properly
sized and installed GHPs deliver more energy per unit consumed than
conventional systems.
And
since geothermal heat pumps are generally more efficient, they are less
expensive to operate and maintain — typical annual energy savings
range from 30% to 60%. Depending on factors such as climate, soil
conditions, the system features you choose, and available financing and
incentives, you may even recoup your initial investment in two to ten
years through lower utility bills.
But
when included in a mortgage, your GHP will have a positive cash flow
from the beginning. For example, say that the extra $3,500 will add $30
per month to each mortgage payment. The energy cost savings will easily
exceed that added mortgage amount over the course of each year.
On
a retrofit, the GHP's high efficiency typically means much lower utility
bills, allowing the investment to be recouped in two to ten years. It
may also be possible to include the purchase of a GHP system in an
"energy-efficient mortgage" that would cover this and other
energy-saving improvements to the home. Banks and mortgage companies can
provide more information on these loans.
There
may be a number of special financing options and incentives available to
help offset the cost of adding a geothermal heat pump (GHP) to your
home. These provisions are available from federal, state, and local
governments; power providers; and banks or mortgage companies that offer
energy-efficient mortgage loans for energy-saving home improvements. Be
sure the system you're interested in qualifies for available incentives
before you make your final purchase.
To
find out more about financing and incentives that are available to you,
visit the Database of State Incentives for Renewable Energy (DSIRE) Web
site. The site is frequently updated with the latest incentives. You
should also check with your electric utility and ask if they offer any
rebates, financing, or special electric rate programs.
Evaluating
Your Site for a Geothermal Heat Pump
Because
shallow ground temperatures are relatively constant throughout the
United States
, geothermal heat pumps (GHPs) can be effectively used almost anywhere.
However, the specific geological, hydrological, and spatial
characteristics of your land will help your local system
supplier/installer determine the best type of ground loop for your site:
Geology
Factors
such as the composition and properties of your soil and rock (which can
affect heat transfer rates) require consideration when designing a
ground loop. For example, soil with good heat transfer properties
requires less piping to gather a certain amount of heat than soil with
poor heat transfer properties. The amount of soil available contributes
to system design as well — system suppliers in areas with extensive
hard rock or soil too shallow to trench may install vertical ground
loops instead of horizontal loops.
Hydrology
Ground
or surface water availability also plays a part in deciding what type of
ground loop to use. Depending on factors such as depth, volume, and
water quality, bodies of surface water can be used as a source of water
for an open-loop system, or as a repository for coils of piping in a
closed-loop system. Ground water can also be used as a source for
open-loop systems, provided the water quality is suitable and all ground
water discharge regulations are met.
Before
you purchase an open-loop system, you will want to be sure your system
supplier/installer has fully investigated your site's hydrology, so you
can avoid potential problems such as aquifer depletion and groundwater
contamination. Antifreeze fluids circulated through closed-loop systems
generally pose little to no environmental hazard.
Land
Availability
The
amount and layout of your land, your landscaping, and the location of
underground utilities or sprinkler systems also contribute to your
system design. Horizontal ground loops (generally the most economical)
are typically used for newly constructed buildings with sufficient land.
Vertical installations or more compact horizontal "Slinky™"
installations are often used for existing buildings because they
minimize the disturbance to the landscape.
Installing
Geothermal Heat Pumps
Because
of the technical knowledge and equipment needed to properly install the
piping, a GHP system installation is not a do-it-yourself project. To
find a qualified installer, call your local utility company, the
International Ground Source Heat Pump Association or the Geothermal Heat
Pump Consortium for their listing of qualified installers in your area.
Installers should be certified and experienced. Ask for references,
especially for owners of systems that are several years old, and check
them.
The
ground heat exchanger in a GHP system is made up of a closed or open
loop pipe system. Most common is the closed loop, in which high density
polyethylene pipe is buried horizontally at 4-6 feet deep or vertically
at 100 to 400 feet deep. These pipes are filled with an environmentally
friendly antifreeze/water solution that acts as a heat exchanger. In the
winter, the fluid in the pipes extracts heat from the earth and carries
it into the building. In the summer, the system reverses and takes heat
from the building and deposits it to the cooler ground.
The
air delivery ductwork distributes the heated or cooled air through the
house's duct work, just like conventional systems. The box that contains
the indoor coil and fan is sometimes called the air handler because it
moves house air through the heat pump for heating or cooling. The air
handler contains a large blower and a filter just like conventional air
conditioners.
Most
geothermal heat pumps are automatically covered under your homeowner's
insurance policy. Contact your insurance provider to find out what its
policy is. Even if your provider will cover your system, it is best to
inform them in writing that you own a new system.
ELECTRIC-POWERED HEAT PUMPS
AND HVAC SYSTEMS
Resistance
Heat
Conventional
electric resistance heating systems use resistance coils, which grow hot
when electric current is applied to them, to generate heat. The system's
blower distributes this heat throughout the house. Electric resistance
heat has a COP equal to one (1.0).
Air-to-Air
Heat Pumps
Air-to-air
heat pumps use an arrangement of compressors, condensers, expansion
valves, and other components to extract heat from outside air in winter.
They also provide cooling in the summer by reversing the process and
dumping heat from inside your home to the outside. On the average, heat
pumps cost 40 to 65 percent less to operate for heat than electric
resistance units.
At
lower temperatures, typically below 30 degrees, air-to-air heat pumps
can no longer extract sufficient heat from outside air to heat a house.
When this happens, a separate electric resistance heater comes on to
provide back-up heating. Fortunately, the time during which the
resistance heater must operate in winter is relatively limited because
of Louisiana's usually mild weather.
Heat
pumps are rated in terms of Seasonal Energy Efficiency Ratio (SEER) for
summer performance and Coefficient of Performance (COP) for winter
performance. Select a unit with a SEER greater than 10, and a COP over
2.9 for the high temperature (47 degrees) and a COP greater than 2.0 for
the low temperature (17 degrees). These high and low temperatures are
important in the design of the equipment and provide information about
its operating efficiency. For comparison, note that electric resistance
heating equipment has a COP equal to 1 .0.
Advantages
of air-to-air heat pumps
-
Heat
pumps provide both heating and air conditioning.
-
Heat
pumps are most advantageous when electricity is the only power
source available.
-
Heat
pumps can supply hot water with the excess heat they generate.
Disadvantages
of air-to-air heat pumps
-
In
the winter, the performance of air-to-air heat pumps decreases as
the temperature declines. They require backup systems of heating to
operate when the outside temperature is too cold. This varies
according to model and manufacturer, but is between 15 and 30
degrees. The back-up systems may be electric resistance heat or a
dual fuel heat pump which uses gas for the back-up system.
Do
not use a setback thermostat with a heat pump; it can cause the
resistance heaters to operate when they are not needed, thereby
increasing utility bills.
EARTH-COUPLED HEAT PUMPS
An
earth-coupled heat pump takes advantage of the more constant earth
temperatures to operate. Transferring of heat from the ground is
accomplished by placing a closed loop of pipe under the ground. The pipe
is then filled with water, brine or antifreeze. During the heating season,
the thermal energy of the ground warms the liquid in the pipe, and this
warm liquid is pumped to the house where it is used by the heating system.
In the cooling season, heat from the house is transferred to the liquid in
the pipe, and pumped through the pipe back to the ground where it loses
heat.
The
most common way of using the energy extracted from the earth is to couple
the coils with a water-to-air heat pump. Heat pumps increase the benefits
of using the earth as a source of energy, can be used in many different
situations, and can provide both heating and cooling.
When
heat pumps are coupled with earth loop systems, they are used to extract
heat from the water (or brine or antifreeze) that is circulated through
the systems. These heat pumps are called water-source heat pumps because
they draw heat from the water or other liquid circulating through the
coils or pipes. If the heat pumps use a forced air system to heat the
home, they are called water-to-air heat pumps. Water-to-air heat pumps are
the most common type of residential water-source heat pumps.
In
Louisiana, the temperature of the earth at a depth of twelve feet averages
67 degrees in the south, and about 65 degrees in the northern part of the
state. This ground temperature is much more stable than air temperature
where extreme highs or lows increase the cost of operating the equipment.
While the efficiency of an earthcoupled heat pump depends on the
temperature of the earth, a COP range of 3 to 4 is normal. The higher the
COP, the higher the efficiency.
One
of the disadvantages of earth-coupled heat pumps is the relatively high
initial cost. The retail cost of a residential water-source heat pump can
be as high as $3000. Wells or earth coils also add to the cost, often as
much as the cost of the heat pump itself. If a heat pump replaces a
heating system that uses forced air in an existing house, duct systems may
need to be changed, adding more to the cost of the system.
Most
heat pumps available now are well made and reliable, but because they are
more complex and have more moving parts than furnaces, conscientious
maintenance is important to keep them operating at their peak.
The
combination of high initial cost and varying operating costs, requires a
full and careful analysis of long-term economics before purchasing a heat
pump system.
ADVANTAGES
OF AN EARTH-COUPLED HEAT PUMP
-
Energy
savings of 30 to 50 percent over typical air-cooled heat pumps.
-
Eliminates
all outdoor air conditioning units as well as cooling towers or
boilers. Corrosion, dirt, vandalism, theft, and high maintenance are
eliminated.
-
No
additional outdoor space is required. Earth bores can be put under
lawns, landscape zones, driveways and parking lots.
-
"Free"
hot water can be produced during the summer months.
-
Elimination
of backup electric resistance heat that is required with air-to-air
heat pump.
DISADVANTAGES
OF AN EARTH-COUPLED HEAT PUMP
-
Initial
installation cost is up to 2.5 times as expensive as other types of
equipment due to the cost of installing wells.
-
Not
all air conditioning contractors are familiar with this technology.
-
Payback
period increases as the energy efficiency of the home goes up.
HIGH EFFICIENCY AIR CONDITIONING
When
selecting new air conditioning equipment, remember that an air conditioner
has two functions. In addition to cooling the indoor air, it also removes
excess humidity. In Louisiana's climate, the removal of humidity is at
least as important as cooling the air. If a unit is not sized properly, it
will not perform both of these functions satisfactorily. A unit that is
oversized for the building it services cools the air quickly, but does not
run long enough to remove excess humidity. This means that to provide
comfort, the thermostat must be turned lower, thus using more energy.
Moreover, the unit cycles on and off frequently. This uses more
electricity than running continuously for longer periods.
Manufacturers
are now making air conditioning equipment that is far more efficient than
standard equipment of a few years ago. Efficiency for central units is
rated according to the Seasonal Energy Efficiency Rating. This indicates
how well the system performs over an entire cooling season. The higher the
rating, the more efficient the equipment.
Determining
the most advantageous rating to purchase depends on the balance between
the cost of the new equipment and the money saved over the life of the
system. A few years ago a rating of 8 was considered efficient. Today,
central units with a rating of 15 are available. Generally, money spent on
the initial cost of efficient equipment pays for itself quickly. To
determine if the cost will be worth it to you, use this formula to compare
the cost of operating equipment with different SEER ratings.
The
newest development in efficient air conditioning equipment is the use of
variable speed fans. By circulating the air at 900 cfm for a longer period
of time, greater dehumidification, and thus greater comfort, can be
achieved.
Cooling
capacity
(BTU/hour)
|
X
|
Cooling
load*
(hours/year)
|
X
|
Electric
rate
|
=
|
Annual
cost
|
|
SEER
|
1000
|
*Alexandria
= 1350 Baton Rouge = 1500 New 0rleans = 1550 Shreveport = 1200
COST ANALYSIS TO COMPARE DIFFERENT KINDS OF EQUIPMENT
The
best way to evaluate the cost effectiveness of a heating and cooling
system is to calculate a life cycle cost analysis. This method of analysis
uses three main cost factors: the initial cost of buying and installing
the equipment, the cost of energy over the lifetime of the equipment, and
the cost of maintaining the equipment. A thorough life cycle cost analysis
should also consider three economic factors that can have a dramatic
effect on life cycle costs: the interest rate, the fuel cost escalation
rate, and the general inflation rate. For example, more expensive
equipment may have to be paid for with borrowed money, and higher interest
rates mean that the equipment will cost more because money is more
expensive. On the other hand, the higher the escalation rate for fuel
costs, the more money an efficient system will save.
Unfortunately,
interest rates, inflation and fuel costs over 20 or 30 years are
impossible to predict, and the formulas for considering these variables
are complex. The cost analysis method that follows is a relatively simple
way to find out how the costs of different heating and cooling systems
compare using three basic cost elements: equipment costs, energy costs,
and maintenance costs. It does not consider the economic variables, and
the numbers used in the examples are very generalized. Despite the
limitations, the cost information presented provides a basic yet useful
way to compare costs of different heating and cooling systems.
DETERMINE
THE COST PER UNIT OF ENERGY
A
long-term energy price rise may be inevitable, but the rise may not be as
dramatic as in the past. It also is difficult to say how the price of one
energy source will compare with another. Consequently, current energy
prices and trends may be used to give some indication of the relative
costs of different energy sources in the future.
Energy
prices also vary by location. Utility companies (or your utility bill) can
provide the current prices for your energy sources.
Natural
Gas*
$4.00 per thousand cubic feet.
Electricity*
$0.08 per kilowatt-hour (kWh)
*Utility
rates reflect actual costs of base rates plus fuel adjustment charges paid
by customers of Louisiana utilities in January, 1987.
DETERMINE
THE COST PER MILLION BTU's
To
compare the cost effectiveness of various heating and cooling systems, it
is necessary to convert the costs of different energy sources to a common
base. The cost per million British thermal units (MBtu's) is commonly
used.
To
find the cost per MBtu's multiply the unit costs by the multipliers used
in this example.
Natural
Gas
$4.00 per mscf x .97 = $3.88 per MBtu's
Electricity
$0.08 per kWh 293 = $23.44 per MBtu's
DETERMINE
THE ENERGY EFFICIENCY OF THE HEATING AND COOLING SYSTEMS
To
find out how different options translate into savings, and how the savings
between systems compare with each other, the efficiencies of all systems
being considered must be known. Find out the efficiency ratings of each
piece of equipment that you are considering. If a heat pump is one of the
options, be sure to get both the COP and SEER ratings. If electric central
air conditioning may be used in conjunction with a gas-burning furnace,
the efficiencies of both units must be considered.
DETERMINE
THE COST PER MBTU OF HEAT DELIVERED
Now
that the cost of energy and the efficiencies of the heating and cooling
systems are known, the cost per MBtu's can be calculated. Divide the cost
per MBtu's of energy that goes into the heating system by the efficiency
rating for the system to get the cost per MBtu's of heat delivered.
FOR
EXAMPLE:
-
Natural
Gas Furnace
|
$3.88
per MBtu's imput =
|
$5.79
per MBtu's delivered
|
|
.67
AFUE
|
-
Electric
Resistance Heat
|
$23.44
per MBtu's imput=
|
$23.44
per MBtu's delivered
|
|
1.0
COP
|
-
Conventional
air conditioning (SEER 6.82)
|
Rate
X 1000 =
|
.08
X 1000 =
|
$11.72
per MBtu's delivered
|
|
SEER
|
6.82
|
Air-to-air
heat pump (heating, COP 3)
|
$23.44
per MBtu's imput =
|
$7.81
per MBtu's delivered
|
|
3.0
COP*
|
-
Air-to-air
heat pump (cooling, SEER 8.53)
|
Rate
X 1000 =
|
.08
X 1000 =
|
$9.38
per MBtu's delivered
|
|
SEER
|
8.53
|
-
Earth-coupled
heat pump (heating, COP 4)
|
$23.44
per MBtu's imput =
|
$5.86
per MBtu's delivered
|
|
4.0
COP*
|
-
Earth-coupled
heat pump (cooling, SEER 10.24)
|
Rate
X 1000 =
|
.08
X 1000 =
|
$7.81
per MBtu's delivered
|
|
SEER
|
10.24
|
*Be
sure to compute this step with actual ratings of equipment under
consideration, since these ratings can vary widely. For a gas furnace,
.67 has been chosen as representative of the COP of equipment
installed prior to 1980. For electric air conditioning, the SEER 6.82
has been chosen as representative of equipment installed prior to
1980.
DETERMINE THE ANNUAL ENERGY CONSUMPTION IN BTU's
An
analysis of conservation and weatherization opportunities is the necessary
first step in deciding on the size and characteristics of the heating and
cooling equipment that will be needed. This step in the cost analysis
assumes that existing homes have been suitably weatherized and that new
homes have been planned with conservation in mind.
For
new construction, a thermal load analysis should be an integral part of
planning for the heating and cooling system. For an existing weatherized
home, a careful energy audit and thermal load analysis will provide
information on the amount of heating that will be required. Utility
records for existing homes normally do not differentiate between heating
and cooling energy demand and other energy uses, such as lighting and
appliances. For the average Louisiana home, about 60 percent of the total
energy consumption is for cooling and heating. The energy consumption for
heating and cooling in well insulated, tight houses can be reduced by as
much as one-half. Because energy consumption patterns can vary so much,
annual heating and cooling demand should be based on a thermal load
analysis, rather than simply summing up a year's utility bills and
eliminating 40 percent for uses other than heating and cooling.
DETERMINE
THE ANNUAL HEATING AND COOLING COST
To
find the annual heating and cooling cost, simply multiply the cost per
MBtu by the annual heating and cooling energy requirement. In the
following examples, it is assumed that 30 MBt l's would be required to
heat the house for a year and 70 MBtu's would be needed for cooling. The
heat pumps would be used for both heating and cooling, requiring 100
MBtu's per year.
For
Example:
-
Natural
Gas Furnace (AFUE .67)
$5.79 per MBtu per year = $174 per year
-
Electric
Resistance Heat (COP 1.0)
$23.44 per MBtu x 30 MBtu's per year = $703 per year
-
Electric
Central Air Conditioning (SEER 6.82)
$11.72 per MBtu x 70 MBtu's per year = $820 per year
-
Air-to-air
Heat Pump (COP 3, SEER 8.53)
|
$7.81
per MBtu x 30 MBtu's per year =
|
$234
per year
|
|
$9.38
per MBtu x 70 MBtu's per year =
|
$657
per year
|
|
$891
Total per year
|
|
$5.86
per MBtu x 30 MBtu's per year =
|
$170
per year
|
|
$7.81
per MBtu x 70 MBtu's per year =
|
$547
per year
|
|
$717
Total per year
|
DETERMINE
THE LIFETIME ENERGY COSTS
Most
heating and cooling units should have useful lives of 20 to 30 years.
Consequently, their costs and potential savings should be figured over
that period. This lifetime energy cost, which in this case does not
consider fuel cost escalation, is calculated by multiplying the annual
cost of energy by the chosen lifetime.
For
example:
-
Natural
Gas
$174 per year x 20 years = $3,840
-
Electric
Resistance
$703 per year x 20 years = $14,060
-
Electric
Central Air Conditioning
$820 per year x 20 years = $16,400
-
Air-to-air
Heat Pump
$890 per year x 20 years = $17,800
-
Earth-coupled
Heat Pump
$717 per year x 20 years = $14,340
DETERMINE
THE COST OF THE EQUIPMENT
When
the heating and cooling costs have been computed, consider the heating and
cooling equipment costs. The easiest way to determine new equipment costs
is to get estimates from dealers. Some of the variables associated with
heating and cooling equipment costs are hard to estimate without knowing
the details of the installation.
One
of these variables is ductwork. For new construction, any forced air
system will require a new duct system, and the costs will be about equal
for furnaces or heat pumps. For heat pumps installed in existing homes,
duct modify ication costs can range from nothing to nearly $1,000.
Prices
vary widely in different parts of the country, but here are some rough
estimates of retail equipment costs (not including installation) to
indicate the relationship between systems of comparable size
(approximately 30,000 Btuh to 40,000 Btuh).
|
Natural
Gas Furnace with flue damper,
electronic ignition, and setback thermostat (AFUE .67)
|
$
750
|
|
High
Efficiency Natural Gas
Combustion Furnace (AFUE .9)
|
$
1,500
|
|
Electric
Resistance Heat
|
$
200
|
|
Electric
Central Air Conditioning
|
$
1,350
|
|
Air-to-air
Heat Pump
|
$
1,850
|
|
Water-to-air
Heat Pump
|
$
1,300
|
DETERMINE THE COST OF MAINTENANCE
Emergency
maintenance costs are nearly impossible to predict, but dealers may be
willing to give estimates of general, annual maintenance costs. However,
even these estimates are likely to vary.
Heat
pumps and air conditioners have one maintenance item that sets them apart
from other systems. While actual performance varies considerably with
specific circumstances, the compressors on heating and cooling heat pumps
may have to replaced after 12 to 15 years. (The U.S. Department of Energy
Technology and Consumer Products Branch indicates that the average
compressor life is 5 to 7 years.) Compressor reliability is increasing all
the time, and there is less stress on water-to-air heat pump compressors
than for air-to-air heat pump compressors, but as of today, one compressor
replacement would be expected for a 20-year life-span. Here are some
maintenance cost estimates for the sake of comparison.
-
Natural
Gas
$50 per year, $1,000 for 20 years
-
Electric
Resistance Heat
$50 per year, $1,000 for 20 years
-
Central
Air Conditioning
|
$50
per year,
|
$1,000
for 20 years
|
|
+
|
for
one compressor*
|
|
1,000
|
|
|
$2,000
|
for
20 years
|
-
Heat
Pumps
|
$75
per year,
|
$1,500
for 20 years
|
|
+
|
for
one compressor*
|
|
1,000
|
|
|
$2,500
|
for
20 years
|
*Cost
of compressor replacement represents 1987 estimate
DETERMINE
THE LIFETIME, "LIFE-CYCLE" COST
A
basic lifetime cost of a heating and cooling system can be determined by
adding up the lifetime energy costs, the initial cost of equipment, and
the cost of maintenance. Remember, this does not consider changes in fuel
costs, inflation, and interest rates over the next 20 years.
For
Example:
-
Natural
gas furnace (AFUE .1 with electric central air conditioning (SEER
6.82)
$
750 gas furnace
1,350 air conditioning
1,000 duct work
$3,100 equipment subtotal
$
3,480 cost of gas
16,400 cost of electricity
$19,880 energy subtotal
$2,000
maintenance cost
$1,000 1 compressor
$3,000 parts and maintenance
$25,980
Total cost for 20 years
-
Earth-coupled
heat pump (COP 4)
$
1,300 heat pump
1,500 coil or well
1,000 duct work
$ 3,800 equipment subtotal
$14,340
electricity
$ 1,500 maintenance
$ 1,000 1 compressor
$ 2,500 parts and maintenance
$20,640
Total cost for 20 years
COST COMMENTS
In
the final example, an earth-coupled heat pump would cost $5,340 less to
own for 20 years than a gas furnace and electric central air conditioning.
This example assumes you are considering replacement of original equipment
on a house built prior to 1980 with an earth-coupled heat pump. A quick
review of the cost analysis step reveals that electric resistance heat
would be the least expensive to buy initially and is virtually maintenance
free, but the electricity costs for 20 years are $14,060, about the same
as would be spent for electricity for both heating and cooling if an
earth-coupled heat pump had been installed.
The
real lesson of this analysis should be that every situation is unique and
must be carefully analyzed. Any one of the factors considered in this
analysis, and the economic variables that are not, (interest rates, fuel
escalation rate, and general inflation rate), may change the outcome. For
example, look at the results if natural gas prices were increased to $8.00
per mcf and electric rates were $.10 per kWh. Or consider the advantage to
be gained with an earth-coupled heat pump if the annual cooling load is
twice the annual heating load. Even when a cost analysis is done as
completely as possible, there will be room for considerable speculation
about what the effects of general economic trends will be. But remember,
any cost analysis will be more meaningful when it is based on the most
specific information available at the time.
How Does an Absorption
Chiller Work?
What is an Absorption Chiller?
Absorption
chillers use heat instead of mechanical energy to provide cooling. A
thermal compressor consists of an absorber, a generator, a pump, and a
throttling device, and replaces the mechanical vapor compressor.
In
the chiller, refrigerant vapor from the evaporator is absorbed by a
solution mixture in the absorber. This solution is then pumped to the
generator. There the refrigerant re-vaporizes using a waste steam heat
source. The refrigerant-depleted solution then returns to the absorber via
a throttling device. The two most common refrigerant/ absorbent mixtures
used in absorption chillers are water/lithium bromide and ammonia/water.
Compared
with mechanical chillers, absorption chillers have a low coefficient of
performance (COP = chiller load/heat input). However, absorption chillers
can substantially reduce operating costs because they are powered by
low-grade waste heat. Vapor compression chillers, by contrast, must be
motor- or engine-driven.
Low-pressure,
steam-driven absorption chillers are available in capacities ranging from
100 to 1,500 tons. Absorption chillers come in two commercially available
designs: single-effect and double-effect. Single-effect machines provide a
thermal COP of 0.7 and require about 18 pounds of
15-pound-per-square-inch-gauge (psig) steam per ton-hour of cooling.
Double-effect machines are about 40% more efficient, but require a higher
grade of thermal input, using about 10 pounds of 100- to 150-psig steam
per ton-hour.
A
single-effect absorption machine means all condensing heat cools and
condenses in the condenser. From there it is released to the cooling
water. A double-effect machine adopts a higher heat efficiency of
condensation and divides the generator into a high-temperature and a
low-temperature generator.
Is It Right for You?
Absorption cooling may be worth considering if your site requires cooling,
and if at least one of the following applies:
-
You have a combined heat and power CHP)
unit and cannot use all of the available heat, or if you are
considering a new CHP plant
-
Waste heat is available
-
A low-cost source of fuels is available
-
Your boiler efficiency is low due to a
poor load factor
-
Your site has an electrical load limit
that will be expensive to upgrade
-
Your site needs more cooling, but has an
electrical load limitation that is expensive to overcome, and you have
an adequate supply of heat.
In
short, absorption cooling may fit when a source of free or low-cost heat
is available, or if objections exist to using conventional refrigeration.
Essentially, the low-cost heat source displaces higher-cost electricity in
a conventional chiller.
In
Practice
In a plant where low-pressure steam is currently being vented to the
atmosphere, a mechanical chiller with a COP of 4.0 is used 4,000 hours a
year to produce an average 300 tons of refrigeration. The plant's cost of
electricity is $0.05 a kilowatt-hour.
An absorption unit requiring 5,400 lbs/hr of 15-psig steam could replace
the mechanical chiller, providing annual electrical cost savings of:
Annual
Savings = 300 tons x (12,000 Btu/ton / 4.0) x 4,000 hrs/yr x $0.05/kWh x
kWh/3,413 Btu = $52,740
Actions You Can Take
Determine
the cost-effectiveness of displacing a portion of your cooling load with a
waste steam absorption chiller by taking the following steps:
-
Conduct a plant survey to identify
sources and availability of waste steam
-
Determine cooling load requirements and
the cost of meeting those requirements with existing mechanical
chillers or new installations
-
Obtain installed cost quotes for a waste
steam absorption chiller
-
Conduct a life cycle cost analysis to
determine if the waste steam absorption chiller meets your company's
cost-effectiveness criteria.
Absorption Chiller Refrigeration
Cycle
The basic cooling cycle is
the same for the absorption and electric chillers. Both systems use a
low-temperature liquid refrigerant that absorbs heat from the water to be
cooled and converts to a vapor phase (in the evaporator section). The
refrigerant vapors are then compressed to a higher pressure (by a
compressor or a generator), converted back into a liquid by rejecting heat
to the external surroundings (in the condenser section), and then expanded
to a low- pressure mixture of liquid and vapor (in the expander section)
that goes back to the evaporator section and the cycle is repeated.
The basic difference
between the electric chillers and absorption chillers is that an electric
chiller uses an electric motor for operating a compressor used for raising
the pressure of refrigerant vapors and an absorption chiller uses heat for
compressing refrigerant vapors to a high-pressure. The rejected heat from
the power-generation equipment (e.g. turbines, microturbines, and engines)
may be used with an absorption chiller to provide the cooling in a CHP
system.
The basic absorption cycle
employs two fluids, the absorbate or refrigerant, and the absorbent. The
most commonly fluids are water as the refrigerant and lithium bromide as
the absorbent. These fluids are separated and recombined in the absorption
cycle. In the absorption cycle the low-pressure refrigerant vapor is
absorbed into the absorbent releasing a large amount of heat. The liquid
refrigerant/absorbent solution is pumped to a high-operating pressure
generator using significantly less electricity than that for compressing
the refrigerant for an electric chiller. Heat is added at the
high-pressure generator from a gas burner, steam, hot water or hot gases.
The added heat causes the refrigerant to desorb from the absorbent and
vaporize. The vapors flow to a condenser, where heat is rejected and
condense to a high-pressure liquid. The liquid is then throttled though an
expansion valve to the lower pressure in the evaporator where it
evaporates by absorbing heat and provides useful cooling. The remaining
liquid absorbent, in the generator passes through a valve, where its
pressure is reduced, and then is recombined with the low-pressure
refrigerant vapors returning from the evaporator so the cycle can be
repeated.
Absorption chillers are
used to generate cold water (44°F) that is circulated to air handlers in
the distribution system for air conditioning.
"Indirect-fired"
absorption chillers use steam, hot water or hot gases steam from a boiler,
turbine or engine generator, or fuel cell as their primary power input.
Theses chillers can be well suited for integration into a CHP system for
buildings by utilizing the rejected heat from the electric generation
process, thereby providing high operating efficiencies through use of
otherwise wasted energy.
"Direct-fired"
systems contain natural gas burners; rejected heat from these chillers can
be used to regenerate desiccant dehumidifiers or provide hot water.
Commercially absorption
chillers can be single-effect or multiple-effect. The above schematic
refers to a single-effect absorption chiller. Multiple-effect absorption
chillers are more efficient and discussed below.
Multiple-Effect
Absorption Chillers
In a single-effect
absorption chiller, the heat released during the chemical process of
absorbing refrigerant vapor into the liquid stream, rich in absorbent, is
rejected to the environment. In a multiple-effect absorption chiller, some
of this energy is used as the driving force to generate more refrigerant
vapor. The more vapor generated per unit of heat or fuel input, the
greater the cooling capacity and the higher the overall operating
efficiency.
A double-effect chiller
uses two generators paired with a single condenser, absorber, and
evaporator. It requires a higher temperature heat input to operate and
therefore they are limited in the type of electrical generation equipment
they can be paired with when used in a CHP System.
Triple-effect chillers can
achieve even higher efficiencies than the double-effect chillers. These
chillers require still higher elevated operating temperatures that can
limit choices in materials and refrigerant/absorbent pairs. Triple-effect
chillers are under development by manufacturers working in cooperation
with the U.S. Department of Energy.
How
Does an Engine Driven Chiller Work?
Packaged natural gas
engine-driven water chillers and direct expansion (DX) units are now
available. Commercially proven custom and packaged engine-driven
refrigeration units offer excellent reliability and economic advantages
for ice rinks, refrigerated warehouses and other applications. The
industry is also focusing on developing small, engine-driven heating and
cooling systems suitable for small commercial applications.
Operation: Engine-driven
cooling systems employ a conventional vapor compression cycle. Their main
components are the compressor, condenser, expansion valve and evaporator.
Advantages: The main difference
between a natural gas and conventional electric system is the replacement
of the electric motor with a gas engine. This change results in
variable-speed operation capability; higher part-load efficiency;
efficient high-temperature waste-heat recovery for water heating, process
heating, or steam generation; and an overall reduction in operating
expenses.
* Requires no more room
than conventional electric chillers
* Lowest operating cost of
any available chiller
* Depending on electric
rates and natural gas rates, an engine driven chiller may operate at up to
1/2 of the cost of direct-fired absorption chillers
*
Like absorption chillers, engine driven chillers reduce on-peak
electric demand charges.
* Depending on your
electric and/or natural gas supplier, there may be rebates available for
purchasing a new absorption chiller or engine driven chiller from your
utility supplier.
* Environmentally friendly.
For
more information on absorption chillers, call
us at: 832-758-0027
www.AbsorptionChillers.comTM
*
Some of the above information from the Department of Energy website and
Louisiana Department of Natural Resources.
|